printRussian science fiction in the Genre of Alternative History as a Reflection of Mass Consciousness:
Sociological Approaches
Аbramov R.N.
Dr. Sci. (Sociol.), Professor Department of Sociology, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Leading Research Fellow of the International Laboratory for Social Integration Research NRU HSE; Senior fellow Institute of Sociology of the Federal Center of Theoretical and Applied Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia, Moscow socioportal@yandex.ru
Rubric: Sociology of culture
For citation:
Аbramov R.N. Russian science fiction in the Genre of Alternative History as a Reflection of Mass Consciousness: Sociological Approaches. Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya [Sociological Studies]. 2023. No 4. P. 106-116
Abstract
In Russia, fiction in the genre of alternative history has become popular over the past ten years. Book series of this kind are actively published and have a significant readership. This genre is part of ideological and utopian landscape of the Russian mass consciousness. It helps to understand imperial historical traumas, nostalgia for the Soviet past, and a high level of anxiety about the present and future. The theoretical part of the analysis is based on the G. Rosenfeld ideas about a close connection of this genre with the experience of the present and about ontological pluralization of the past. The article also includes M. Laruelle’s thesis about the ideological function of this genre and its role in ideological mobilization. The concept of E. Shatsky’s utopia as a chronic escapism is an important element in the analysis of this genre in Russia. Russian science fiction in the genre of alternative history mirrors ideological and utopian unconscious, which articulates affective historical traumas of society. Alternative history novels actively experiment with genres, and it contains elements of a political detective story, adventure and spy novel, conspiracy theories, personal nostalgic memoirs about childhood and adolescence, mysticism, military action movie, romance, crypto-fiction. Many authors perceive their novels as a historical experiment, and they are concerned with problematizing the causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union. The modern Russian wave of science fiction in the genre of alternative history is a more painful reaction of a part of society to the deep historical faults associated with the collapse of the USSR. The source of the analysis is the materials of interviews with the authors of works in the genre of alternative history, readers’ reviews on thematic online platforms and the content of the works.
Keywords
ressentiment; mass consciousness; alternative history; ideology; nostalgia
References
Abramov R.N. (2017) Soviet Technocratic Mythologies as a Form of the “Missed Chance Theory”: on the example of the history of cybernetics in the USSR. Sociology of science and technology [Sotsiologiya nauki i tekhnologiy]. No. 2: 61–78. (In Russ.)
Benjamin V. (2021) Fate and character. St. Petersburg: Azbuka. (In Russ.)
Boltanski L. (2016) Secrets and conspiracies. Following investigations. St. Petersburg: EU. (In Russ.)
Borenstein E. (2019) Plots against Russia. Conspiracy and Fantasy after Socialism. London: Cornell University Press.
Danilova E.N. (2014) The discourse of winners and losers in Russian transformations. Sociological Research [Sotsiologicheskiye issledovaniya]. No. 5: 16–26. (In Russ.)
Gudkov L., Dubin B. (1994) Literature as a social institution. Moscow: New Literary Review. (In Russ.)
Howell I. (2021) Apocalyptic realism. Science fiction by Arkady and Boris Strugatsky. St. Petersburg: BiblioRossika. (In Russ.)
Hellekson K. (2000) The Alternate History: Refiguring Historical Time. Kent: The Kent State University Press.
Jameson F. (2019) Postmodernism, or the cultural logic of late capitalism. Moscow: Gaidar Institute. (In Russ.)
Laruelle M. (2012) Conspiracy and Alternate History in Russia: A Nationalist Equation for Success? The Russian Review. Vol. 71. No. 4: 565–580.
Nefedov S.A., Rozov N.S., Trubitsyn D.V., Romanovsky N.V. (2022) Russia: from the past to the future (round table on the book by B.N. Mironov). Sociological Research [Sotsiologicheskiye issledovaniya]. No. 3: 24–39. (In Russ.)
Powell Z.M. (2018) The Ethics of Alternate History. Melodrama and Political Engagement in Amazon’s The Man in the High Castle. South Atlantic Review. No. 3 (83): 150–169.
Rosenfeld G.D. (2005) The World Hitler Never Made: Alternate History and the Memory of Nazism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Shatsky E. Utopia and tradition. Moscow: Progress, 1990. (In Russ.)
Thiess D.J. (2015) Relativism, Alternate History, and the Forgetful Reader. Reading Science Fiction and Historiography. London: Lexington Books.
Zavadsky A., Sklez V., Suverina K. (2019) Preface. Reason and Feelings: Public History in the Museum. Politics of Affect. Museum as a Space of Public History. Moscow: New Literary Review: 7–51. (In Russ.)
Zhavoronkov A.V., Levashov V.K., Obraztsov I.V., Rostovtseva L.I., Romanovsky N.V., Trofimova I.N., Chernysh M.F., Demidenko S.Yu. (2020) Non-cooling memory (round table). Sociological research [Sotsiologicheskiye issledovaniya]. No. 5: 3–17. (In Russ.)
Content No 4, 2023